- Fed officials remain split over the future of rate cuts, citing conflicting signals from inflation and labor market data.
- While the FOMC approved a quarter-point cut in October, “many” participants don’t see a need for further easing in 2025.
- Market expectations for a December cut have dropped sharply, with odds now at just 33%.
- Two members dissented at the October meeting, highlighting rare friction within the central bank.
Fed Uncertainty Builds Ahead of December
Minutes from the Federal Reserve’s October meeting reveal widening disagreement among policymakers, per CNBC. While they agreed to lower rates by a quarter point, their outlook for December remains unclear. Chair Jerome Powell stressed that another cut is not a “foregone conclusion.”
Some participants favored a December move if conditions stay the same. However, “many” said the Fed should hold rates steady for the rest of the year. In Fed language, “many” outweighs “several,” signaling a possible pause. Still, the minutes don’t show how voting members stand. Only 12 of the 19 participants vote.
Inflation vs. Labor Market Pressures
At the heart of the debate is a conflict between the Fed’s dual goals: price stability and full employment. Some members, like Governors Stephen Miran and Christopher Waller, support further cuts to help a weakening labor market. Others, including regional Presidents Jeffrey Schmid and Susan Collins, fear easing too soon could derail progress on inflation.
Officials noted inflation remains above the 2% target, despite signs of slowing. The minutes also show concern about weak job growth. Without clear signals, the Fed faces pressure from both sides.
Rare Dissent Reveals Growing Tension
The October decision passed with a 10–2 vote. Miran pushed for a deeper, 50-basis-point cut, while Schmid opposed any move at all—marking only the second dual dissent in three decades. This rare split reflects growing friction inside the Fed, as officials weigh opposing risks tied to inflation and a cooling labor market. That internal tension has been building for weeks, as seen in the ongoing debate among Fed officials over economic uncertainty.
Some experts worry that public division could hurt the Fed’s credibility. Markets might read conflicting messages as signs of disarray.
Get Smarter about what matters in CRE
Stay ahead of trends in commercial real estate with CRE Daily – the free newsletter delivering everything you need to start your day in just 5-minutes
Markets Adjust to the Fed’s Uncertainty
Investor expectations have shifted quickly. At the start of November, markets saw a 67% chance of a December cut. By mid-November, that dropped to 33%, according to CME’s FedWatch tool. The odds for a January cut remain higher at 66%.
The Fed still expects more cuts in the future. But officials don’t agree on timing. For now, they’re taking a wait-and-see approach.
Missing Data Complicates Fed’s Decisions
The recent 44-day government shutdown disrupted key economic reports. The Fed lacked data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics and other agencies, including the September jobs report. Powell compared policymaking during this time to “driving in the fog.” Governor Waller disagreed, saying the Fed still had enough data.
The loss of key metrics added to the uncertainty heading into December’s meeting. Without full visibility, officials had to rely on partial information to make major decisions.
What’s Next
The Fed meets again on December 9–10. Whether it cuts rates again will depend on new data and internal consensus. Officials must weigh inflation risks against a softening job market—all while trying to maintain credibility with investors.
For now, markets remain cautious. The Fed’s next move is still in play, but the divisions inside the committee are clearer than ever.
